HALAL MEAT FRAUD AND SAFETY ISSUES IN THE MALAYSIAN AND INDONESIAN MARKETS
Abstract
In recent years, interest in meat issues and research have increased. Many consumers are concerned about the meat they eat because it's the main source of protein in daily consumption. However, in issues pertaining to meat, halal and safety are of vital focus for Muslim consumers, especially in the Southeast Asia region. Some of the related issues in halal and safety meat are criminal and terrorist activities, including meat fraud such as adulterant substances (adulteration), substitution, stolen livestock, grey market product, smuggling, misrepresentation or mislabeling etc. In parallel with fraudulent meat activities, perpetrators tend to use a harmful and unsafety material in the meat product, namely glonggong meat, formalin meat, tiren meat, exotic meat etc. Thus, this review is intended to provide an overview of halal and safety issues in a meat product in the Malaysian and Indonesian markets. The findings show that various fraudulent actions can threaten the lives of humans, animals and other food sources as well as opposed to Shariah guidance. Therefore, all parties need to mobilise a regional collaboration in combating food perpetrators and terrorists to ensure that the meat products in the market fit with the halalan tayyiba criteria. At the same time, this collaboration will boost regional halal ecosystems to grow rapidly, especially in Southeast Asia.
References
Ahmad, A.F., (2010). Mengesan Pengawet Mayat pada Makanan, Utusan Malaysia.
Arthur, Y., (2007). Formaldehyde in Food, Food Safety Focus (6th Issue, January 2007), http://www.cfs.gov.hk/english/multimedia/multimedia_pub/multimedia_pub_fsf_06_01.html
Ballin, N.Z., (2010). Authentication of Meat and Meat Products, Meat Science 86, 577–587.
Batt, C.A., (2016). Food Defense, Elsevier.
Beck, U. (2002). The Terrorist Threat: World Risk Society Revisited, Theory, Culture & Society, London: Thousand Oaks, 19(4): 39–55.
Bekker, G.A., Tobi, H., and Fischer, A.R.H., (2017). Meet Meat: An Explorative Study on Meat and Cultured Meat as Seen by Chinese, Ethiopians and Dutch, Appetite 114, 82-92.
Black, C., Chevallier, O.P., and Elliott, C.T., (2016). The Current and Potential Applications of Ambient Mass Spectrometry in Detecting Food Fraud, Trends in Analytical Chemistry 82, 268–278.
Brunet, S., Delvenne, P. and Claisse, F., (2010). Food Chain Security and Vulnerability, Food Chain Security, edited by Hami Alpas & Beyazit Cirakoglu, Netherlands: Springer.
Caldasa, M.M. and Perz, S., (2013). Agro-Terrorism? The Causes and Consequences of The Appearance of Witch’s Broom Disease in Cocoa Plantations of Southern Bahia, Brazil, Geoforum 47, 147–157.
Campbell, J.R., (2012). Human Health Threats and Implications for Regional Security in Southeast Asia, B.C.G. Teh (ed.), Human Security: Securing East Asia’s Future, Springer Science+Business Media, 173-191.
Carus, W.S. (2001). Bioterrorism and Biocrimes: The Illicit Use of Biological Agents Since 1900, Washington: Center for Counterproliferation Research, 181-182.
CATRC, (2010), The Counter Agro Terrorism Research Center, http://catrc.realdesign.co.il/
Cawthorn, D.M., & Hoffman, L.C., (2015). The Bushmeat and Food Security Nexus: A Global Account of The Contributions, Conundrums and Ethical Collisions, Food Research International 76, 906–925.
Charlebois, S., Schwab, A., Henn, R., Huck, C.W., (2016). Food Fraud: An Exploratory Study For Measuring Consumer Perception Towards Mislabeled Food Products and Influence on Self-Authentication Intentions, Trends in Food Science & Technology 50, 211-218.
Chuah, L.O., He, X.B., Effarizah, M.E., Syahriza, Z.A., Shamila-Syuhada, A.K. and Rusul, G., (2016). Mislabelling of Beef and Poultry Products Sold in Malaysia, Food Control, 62, 157-164.
Diamante, Christine Jade B. (n.d.), Food Insecurity: The Experiences Of Hunger Among The Households Living In Manila A Slum, hd-ca.org/wp-content/.../Diamante-Food%20Insecurity-.pdf
Dubey, J.P., (2015). Foodborne and Waterborne Zoonotic Sarcocystosis, Food and Waterborne Parasitology 1, 2–11.
Ereifej, K.I., (2011). Establishing Database for Food Products and Ingredients to Strengthen Readiness in Food Terrorism Attack, Advances in Food Protection Focus on Food Safety and Defense, edited by Magdy Hefnawy, Netherlands: Springer.
Fitzpatrick, J.L., (2013). Global Food Security: The Impact of Veterinary Parasites and Parasitologists, Veterinary Parasitology 195, 233– 248
Hamdan, M.N., Post, M.J., Ramli, M.A. and Mustafa, A.R., (2017). Cultured Meat in Islamic Perspective, Journal of Religion and Health, 1–14.
Hansen, C., (2010). An Exploration of Potential Chemical and Biological Threat Agents, Threats to Food and Water Chain Infrastructure, edited by Virginia Koukouliou, Magdalena Ujevic & Otto Premstaller, (Springer Science + Business Media, 2010), 14-24.
Hargin, K.D., (1996). Authenticity Issues in Meat and Meat Products, Meat Science 43(96), 277-289.
Jakesa, W., Gerdova, A., Defernez, M., Watson, A.D., McCallum, C., Limer, E., Colquhoun, I.J., Williamson, D.C. and Kemsley, E.K., (2015). Authentication of Beef Versus Horse Meat Using 60 Mhz H NMR Spectroscopy, Food Chemistry 175, 1–9.
Kinsey, J., Stinson, T., Degeneffe, D., Ghosh, K. and Busta, F., (2009). Consumer Response to a New Food Safety Issue: Food Terrorism, Global Issues in Food Science and Technology, edited by Gustavo Barbosa-Cánovas, Alan Mortimer, David Lineback, Walter Spiess, Ken Buckle and Paul Colonna, San Diego: Academic Press, 145-161.
Kosmo, (t.t.). Tragedi Ayam Masak Merah, http://www.kosmo.com.my/kosmo/content.asp? y=2013&dt=1006&pub=Kosmo&sec= Rencana_Utama&pg=ru_09.htm.
Laila, T.M. (2013). Bahan Berbahaya Di Sekitar Kita. Solo : Aqwamedika.
Lister, S.A. and Becker, G.S., (2009). Bovine Spongiform Encephalopathy (BSE, or 'Mad Cow Disease'): Current and Proposed Safeguards, New York: Nova Science Publishers Inc.
Liu, J., Cao, Y., Wang, Q., Pan, W., Ma, F., Liu, C., Chen, W., Yang, J. and Zheng, L., (2016). Rapid and Nondestructive Identification of Water-Injected Beef Samples Using Multispectral Imaging Analysis, Food Chemistry 190, 938–943.
Mahallawi, W.H. (2017). Case Report: Detection of The Middle East Respiratory Syndrome Corona Virus (MERS-Cov) In Nasal Secretions of A Dead Human, Journal of Taibah University Medical Sciences, 1-3.
Malaysia, (2009). MS 1500:2009: Halal Food-Production, Preparation, Handling and Storage-General Guidelines (second revision), Department of Standard Malaysia.
Manning, L., (2016). Food Fraud: Policy and Food Chain, Current Opinion in Food Science, 10:16–21.
Manning, L., Smith, R. and Soon, J.M., (2016). Developing an Organizational Typology of Criminals in The Meat Supply Chain, Food Policy 59, 44–54.
McElwee, G., Smith, R., and Lever, J., (2017). Illegal Activity in The UK Halal (Sheep) Supply Chain: Towards Greater Understanding, Food Policy 69, 166–175.
Ministry of Health, (2014). Isu Bekalan Ayam di Utara Semenanjung Malaysia Dicemari Virus Berbahaya, http://fsq.moh.gov/v4/index.php/component/k2/item/653
Montowska, M. and Pospiech, E., (2014). Authenticity Determination of Meat and Meat Products on the Protein and DNA Basis, Food Review International, 27, 84-100.
Nakyinsige, K., Man, Y.C., and Sazili, A.Q., (2012). Halal Authenticity Issues in Meat and Meat Products, Meat Science 91, 207-214.
news.liputan6.com (t.t.), Gudang Penyimpanan Ayam Busuk dan Berformalin di Karawang Digerebek. http://news.liputan6.com/read/3036119/gudang-penyimpanan-ayam-busuk-dan-berformalin-di-karawang-digerebek.
news.liputan6.com (t.t.). Daging Ayam Tiren Berbau dan Berformalin di Karawang. http://news.liputan6.com/read/3036608/daging-ayam-tiren-berbau-dan-berformalin-di-karawang.
news.liputan6.com (t.t.). Puluhan Kilo Daging Sampah Dimusnahkan. http://news.liputan6.com/read/165289/puluhan-kilo-daging-sampah-dimusnahkan.
Prasetyo, A., Soeparno, Suryanto, E. dan Rusman, (2009). Chemical Characteristics And Microstructure Of Longissimus Dorsi And Biceps Femoris Muscle Of Glonggong Beef Cattle. Buletin Peternakan Vol. 33(1): 23-29.
Qureshi, S.S., Jamal, M., Qureshi, M.S., Rauf, M., Syed, B.H. and Zulfiqar, M., (2012). A Review of Halal Food With Special Reference to Meat and Its Trade Potential. Journal of Animal and Plant Sciences, 22, 79-83.
Rahmati, S., Julkapli, N.M., Yehye, W.A. and Basirun, W.J., (2016). Identification of Meat Origin in Food Products Review, Food Control 68, 379-390.
ramadan.sindonews.com (t.t.). Petugas Temukan Pedagang Jual Daging Sisa, http://ramadan.sindonews.com/read/758415/68/petugas-temukan-pedagang-jual-daging-sisa-1373251033.
Rohn, E. and Erez, G., (2013). Framework For Agro-Terrorism Intentions Detection Using Overt Data Sources, Technological Forecasting & Social Change 80, 1877–1884.
Roslan N.I.M., and Abdul Manaf, Y.N., (2014). Isu Penggunaan Lemak Haiwan Dalam Makanan, Isu Halal Kontemporari, edited by Ruslly Abd Rahman, Nurdeng Deuraseh and Mohammad Aizat Jamaludin, Serdang: Universiti Putra Malaysia, 118-137.
Rostami, A., Gamble, H.R., Dupouy-Camet, J., Khazan, H. and Bruschi, F. (2017). Meat Sources of Infection for Outbreaks of Human Trichinellosis. Food Microbiology 64 65-71.
Sandalj, M., Treydte, A.C. and Ziegler, S., (2016). Is Wild Meat Luxury? Quantifying Wild Meat Demand and Availability in Hue, Vietnam, Biological Conservation 194, 105–112.
Saucier, L., (2016). Microbial Spoilage, Quality and Safety Within The Context of Meat Sustainability, Meat Science 120, 78–84.
Sentandreu, M.Á. & Sentandreu, E., (2014). Authenticity of Meat Products: Tools Against Fraud, Food Research International 60, 19–29.
Solodoukhina, D., (2011). Food Safety and Bioterrorism from Public Health Perspective, Advances in Food Protection Focus on Food Safety and Defense, edited by Magdy Hefnawy, Netherlands: Springer, 2011.
Spink, J. and Moyer, D.C. (2011). Defining the Public Health Threat of Food Fraud, Journal of Food Science, 76 (9), 157-163.
Stanciu, S., (2015). Horse Meat Consumption - Between Scandal and Reality, Procedia Economics and Finance 23, 697 – 703.
Stephen, M., (2003). The SARS Epidemic: From Ducks to Pigs to Humans? Wall Street Journal.
Sulistyo, P. and Fikri, A., (2014). Produk Asal Haiwan yang Harus Diwaspadai, Isu Halal Kontemporari, edited by Russly Abd Rahman, Nurdeng Deuraseh and Mohammad Aizat Jamaludin, Serdang: Universiti Putra Malaysia, 150-166.
The Borneo Post (2011). Elak Jual Daging Binatang Liar di Market Teresang, http://www.Theborneopost/2011/04/27/elak-jual-daging-binatang-liar-di-market-teresang.
thestar.com.my (2013). Dangerous Yellow Chicken Colouring Used To Dupe Customers Into Thinking They Are Kampung Variety http://www.thestar.com.my/news/ community/2013/09/24/dangerous-yellow-chicken-colouring-used-to-dupe-customers-into-thinking-they-are-kampung-variety/.
Tucker, J.B. (2002). A Farewell to Germs: The U.S. Renunciation of Biological and ToxinWarfare 1969–1970. International Security, 27(1) 107–148.
Turvey, C.G., Onyango, B., Cuite, C., and Hallman, W.K., (2010). Risk, Fear, Bird Flu And Terrorists: A Study of Risk Perceptions and Economics, The Journal of Socio-Economics 39, 1–10.
White, S.G., (2009). It Happened Here: Biological Terrorism in the United States, A New Understanding of Terrorism: Case Studies, Trajectories and Lessons Learned, edited by M.R. Haberfeld & Agostino von Hassell, London: Springer.
WHO (2017). Factsheets Mers-cov. http://www.who.int/mediacentre/factsheets/mers-cov/en/
WHO (2015). Who Estimates Of The Global Burden Of Foodborne Diseases Foodborne Disease Burden Epidemiology Reference Group 2007-2015. World Health Organization.
www.beritanusantara.id, (2017). Pasar Tomohon Jadi Perhatian Dunia, http://www.beritanusantara.id/2017/05/05/pasar-tomohon-jadi-perhatian-dunia/
www.kosmo.com.my (t.t.), Awas Jualan Daging Rusa Palsu, http://www.kosmo.com.my/kosmo/content.asp?y=2013&dt= 0807&pub=Kosmo&sec= Negara&pg=ne_08.htm
www.nytimes.com (2013). Nestle Remove 2 Products in Horse Meat Scandal, http://www.nytimes.com/2013/02/20/world/europe/nestle-pulls-2-products-in-horse-meat-scandal.html?_r=0&pagewanted=print.
Zhang, W., Naveena, B.M., Jo, C., Sakata, R., Zhou, G., Banerjee, R. and Nishiumi, T., (2017). Technological Demands of Meat Processing–An Asian Perspective, Meat Science 132, 35–44.
Downloads
Published
Issue
Section
License
Author(s) shall retain the copyright of their work and grant the Journal/Publisher right for the first publication with the work simultaneously licensed under:
Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial 4.0 International (CC BY-NC 4.0). This license allows for the copying, distribution and transmission of the work, provided the correct attribution of the original creator is stated. Adaptation and remixing are also permitted.
This broad license intends to facilitate free access to, as well as the unrestricted reuse of, original works of all types for non-commercial purposes.
The author(s) permits HH Publisher to publish this article that has not been submitted elsewhere.
.png){kind=logo}
.jpg)
